| DOKUMENTATION |
|
Der Inhalt dieser Seite entspricht der Abstimmungsliste 2 der 214. Sitzung des Bundestages (30.1.2002), die am 3. Feb. 2002 von der Webseite des Deutschen Bundestages heruntergeladen wurde. Im Original ist ein grosser Teil der Parlamentarier mit dem selben Abstimmungsergebnis doppelt aufgeführt, diese wurden für diese Liste entfernt.
Die übersichtlichste Darstellung wird mit Netscape 4.6 erreicht!
Bei der zweiten Abstimmung ging es noch um folgende Anträge:
|
Drucksache 14/8101 (PDF-Datei)
|
Drucksache 14/8102 (PDF-Datei)
|
| Schutz der Menschenwürde angesichts der biomedizinischen Möglichkeiten - Kein Import embryonaler Stammzellen | Keine verbrauchende Embryonenforschung:
Import humaner embryonaler Stammzellen grundsätzlich verbieten und nur unter engen Voraussetzungen zulassen |
| 265 (43.8%) | 340 (56.2%) |
618, 1 ungültig, 617 gültig, 10 Nein, 2 Enthaltungen
| Name | Drucksache
14/8101 |
Drucksache
14/8102 |
Nein | Enthaltung |
| SPD | ||||
| Brigitte Adler | x | |||
| Gerd Andres | x | |||
| Ingrid Arndt-Brauer | x | |||
| Rainer Arnold | x | |||
| Hermann Bachmaier | x | |||
| Ernst Bahr | x | |||
| Doris Barnett | x | |||
| Eckhardt Barthel (Berlin) | x | |||
| Klaus Barthel (Starnberg) | x | |||
| Ingrid Becker-Inglau | x | |||
| Dr. Axel Berg | x | |||
| Hans-Werner Bertl | x | |||
| Friedhelm Julius Beucher | x | |||
| Petra Bierwirth | x | |||
| Rudolf Bindig | x | |||
| Lothar Binding (Heidelberg) | x | |||
| Kurt Bodewig | x | |||
| Klaus Brandner | x | |||
| Anni Brandt-Elsweier | x | |||
| Willi Brase | x | |||
| Rainer Brinkmann (Detmold) | x | |||
| Bernhard Brinkmann (Hildesheim) | x | |||
| Hans-Günter Bruckmann | x | |||
| Edelgard Bulmahn | x | |||
| Ursula Burchardt | x | |||
| Dr. Michael Bürsch | x | |||
| Hans Martin Bury | x | |||
| Hans Büttner (Ingolstadt) | x | |||
| Marion Caspers-Merk | x | |||
| Wolf-Michael Catenhusen | x | |||
| Dr. Peter Danckert | x | |||
| Dr. Herta Däubler-Gmelin | x | |||
| Christel Deichmann | x | |||
| Karl Diller | x | |||
| Peter Dressen | x | |||
| Detlef Dzembritzki | x | |||
| Dieter Dzewas | x | |||
| Dr. Peter Eckardt | x | |||
| Sebastian Edathy | x | |||
| Ludwig Eich | x | |||
| Marga Elser | x | |||
| Peter Enders | x | |||
| Gernot Erler | x | |||
| Petra Ernstberger | x | |||
| Annette Faße | x | |||
| Lothar Fischer (Homburg) | x | |||
| Gabriele Fograscher | x | |||
| Norbert Formanski | x | |||
| Rainer Fornahl | x | |||
| Hans Forster | x | |||
| Dagmar Freitag | x | |||
| Lilo Friedrich (Mettmann) | x | |||
| Harald Friese | x | |||
| Anke Fuchs (Köln) | x | |||
| Arne Fuhrmann | x | |||
| Monika Ganseforth | x | |||
| Konrad Gilges | x | |||
| Iris Gleicke | x | |||
| Günter Gloser | x | |||
| Uwe Göllner | x | |||
| Günter Graf (Friesoythe) | x | |||
| Angelika Graf (Rosenheim) | x | |||
| Dieter Grasedieck | x | |||
| Monika Griefahn | x | |||
| Kerstin Griese | x | |||
| Achim Großmann | x | |||
| Wolfgang Grotthaus | x | |||
| Karl-Hermann Haack (Extertal) | x | |||
| Hans-Joachim Hacker | x | |||
| Klaus Hagemann | x | |||
| Manfred Hampel | x | |||
| Alfred Hartenbach | x | |||
| Anke Hartnagel | x | |||
| Klaus Hasenfratz | x | |||
| Nina Hauer | x | |||
| Hubertus Heil | x | |||
| Reinhold Hemker | x | |||
| Frank Hempel | x | |||
| Rolf Hempelmann | x | |||
| Dr. Barbara Hendricks | x | |||
| Gustav Herzog | x | |||
| Monika Heubaum | x | |||
| Reinhold Hiller (Lübeck) | x | |||
| Stephan Hilsberg | x | |||
| Gerd Höfer | x | |||
| Jelena Hoffmann (Chemnitz) | x | |||
| Walter Hoffmann (Darmstadt) | x | |||
| Iris Hoffmann (Wismar) | x | |||
| Frank Hofmann (Volkach) | x | |||
| Ingrid Holzhüter | x | |||
| Eike Hovermann | x | |||
| Christel Humme | x | |||
| Lothar Ibrügger | x | |||
| Brunhilde Irber | x | |||
| Gabriele Iwersen | x | |||
| Renate Jäger | x | |||
| Ilse Janz | x | |||
| Dr. Uwe Jens | x | |||
| Volker Jung (Düsseldorf) | x | |||
| Johannes Kahrs | x | |||
| Ulrich Kasparick | x | |||
| Sabine Kaspereit | x | |||
| Susanne Kastner | x | |||
| Hans-Peter Kemper | x | |||
| Klaus Kirschner | x | |||
| Marianne Klappert | x | |||
| Siegrun Klemmer | x | |||
| Walter Kolbow | x | |||
| Fritz Rudolf Körper | x | |||
| Karin Kortmann | x | |||
| Anette Kramme | x | |||
| Nicolette Kressl | x | |||
| Volker Kröning | x | |||
| Angelika Krüger-Leißner | x | |||
| Horst Kubatschka | x | |||
| Ernst Küchler | x | |||
| Helga Kühn-Mengel | x | |||
| Ute Kumpf | x | |||
| Konrad Kunick | x | |||
| Werner Labsch | x | |||
| Christine Lambrecht | x | |||
| Brigitte Lange | x | |||
| Christian Lange (Backnang) | x | |||
| Detlev von Larcher | x | |||
| Waltraud Lehn | x | |||
| Klaus Lennartz | x | |||
| Dr. Elke Leonhard | x | |||
| Eckhart Lewering | x | |||
| Götz-Peter Lohmann (Neubrandenburg) | x | |||
| Gabriele Lösekrug-Möller | x | |||
| Erika Lotz | x | |||
| Dieter Maaß (Herne) | x | |||
| Winfried Mante | x | |||
| Dirk Manzewski | x | |||
| Tobias Marhold | x | |||
| Ulrike Mascher | x | |||
| Christoph Matschie | x | |||
| Heide Mattischeck | x | |||
| Markus Meckel | x | |||
| Ulrike Mehl | x | |||
| Ulrike Merten | x | |||
| Angelika Mertens | x | |||
| Dr. Jürgen Meyer (Ulm) | x | |||
| Ursula Mogg | x | |||
| Christoph Moosbauer | x | |||
| Siegmar Mosdorf | x | |||
| Jutta Müller (Völklingen) | x | |||
| Christian Müller (Zittau) | x | |||
| Franz Müntefering | x | |||
| Andrea Nahles | x | |||
| Volker Neumann (Bramsche) | x | |||
| Gerhard Neumann (Gotha) | x | |||
| Dr. Edith Niehuis | x | |||
| Dr. Rolf Niese | x | |||
| Dietmar Nietan | x | |||
| Günter Oesinghaus | x | |||
| Eckhard Ohl | x | |||
| Leyla Onur | x | |||
| Holger Ortel | x | |||
| Adolf Ostertag | x | |||
| Kurt Palis | x | |||
| Albrecht Papenroth | x | |||
| Dr. Martin Pfaff | x | |||
| Georg Pfannenstein | x | |||
| Johannes Pflug | x | |||
| Dr. Eckhart Pick | x | |||
| Joachim Poß | x | |||
| Karin Rehbock-Zureich | x | |||
| Dr. Carola Reimann | x | |||
| Margot von Renesse | x | |||
| Renate Rennebach | x | |||
| Bernd Reuter | x | |||
| Dr. Edelbert Richter | x | |||
| Christel Riemann-Hanewinckel | x | |||
| Reinhold Robbe | x | |||
| Gudrun Roos | x | |||
| René Röspel | x | |||
| Dr. Ernst Dieter Rossmann | x | |||
| Michael Roth (Heringen) | x | |||
| Birgit Roth (Speyer) | x | |||
| Gerhard Rübenkönig | x | |||
| Marlene Rupprecht | x | |||
| Thomas Sauer | x | |||
| Dr. Hansjörg Schäfer | x | |||
| Gudrun Schaich-Walch | x | |||
| Rudolf Scharping | x | |||
| Bernd Scheelen | x | |||
| Dr. Hermann Scheer | x | |||
| Siegfried Scheffler | x | |||
| Horst Schild | x | |||
| Otto Schily | x | |||
| Dieter Schloten | x | |||
| Horst Schmidbauer (Nürnberg) | x | |||
| Ulla Schmidt (Aachen) | x | |||
| Silvia Schmidt (Eisleben) | x | |||
| Dagmar Schmidt (Meschede) | x | |||
| Wilhelm Schmidt (Salzgitter) | x | |||
| Dr. Frank Schmidt (Weilburg) | x | |||
| Regina Schmidt-Zadel | x | |||
| Heinz Schmitt (Berg) | x | |||
| Carsten Schneider | x | |||
| Dr. Emil Schnell | x | |||
| Walter Schöler | x | |||
| Karsten Schönfeld | x | |||
| Fritz Schösser | x | |||
| Ottmar Schreiner | x | |||
| Gerhard Schröder | x | |||
| Richard Schuhmann (Delitzsch) | x | |||
| Brigitte Schulte (Hameln) | x | |||
| Reinhard Schultz (Everswinkel) | x | |||
| Volkmar Schultz (Köln) | x | |||
| Ewald Schurer | x | |||
| Dr. Angelica Schwall-Düren | x | |||
| Rolf Schwanitz | x | |||
| Bodo Seidenthal | x | |||
| Erika Simm | x | |||
| Dr. Sigrid Skarpelis-Sperk | x | |||
| Wieland Sorge | x | |||
| Wolfgang Spanier | x | |||
| Dr. Margrit Spielmann | x | |||
| Jörg-Otto Spiller | x | |||
| Dr. Ditmar Staffelt | x | |||
| Antje-Marie Steen | x | |||
| Ludwig Stiegler | x | |||
| Rolf Stöckel | x | |||
| Rita Streb-Hesse | x | |||
| Reinhold Strobl (Amberg) | x | |||
| Dr. Peter Struck | x | |||
| Joachim Stünker | x | |||
| Joachim Tappe | x | |||
| Jörg Tauss | x | |||
| Jella Teuchner | x | |||
| Dr. Gerald Thalheim | x | |||
| Wolfgang Thierse | x | |||
| Franz Thönnes | x | |||
| Adelheid Tröscher | x | |||
| Hans-Eberhard Urbaniak | x | |||
| Rüdiger Veit | x | |||
| Simone Violka | x | |||
| Ute Vogt (Pforzheim) | x | |||
| Hans Georg Wagner | x | |||
| Hedi Wegener | x | |||
| Dr. Konstanze Wegner | x | |||
| Wolfgang Weiermann | x | |||
| Matthias Weisheit | x | |||
| Gert Weisskirchen (Wiesloch) | x | |||
| Dr. Ernst Ulrich von Weizsäcker | x | |||
| Jochen Welt | x | |||
| Dr. Rainer Wend | x | |||
| Hildegard Wester | x | |||
| Lydia Westrich | x | |||
| Inge Wettig-Danielmeier | x | |||
| Dr. Margrit Wetzel | x | |||
| Dr. Norbert Wieczorek | x | |||
| Jürgen Wieczorek (Böhlen) | x | |||
| Helmut Wieczorek (Duisburg) | x | |||
| Heidemarie Wieczorek-Zeul | x | |||
| Dieter Wiefelspütz | x | |||
| Heino Wiese (Hannover) | x | |||
| Brigitte Wimmer (Karlsruhe) | x | |||
| Engelbert Wistuba | x | |||
| Barbara Wittig | x | |||
| Dr. Wolfgang Wodarg | x | |||
| Verena Wohlleben | x | |||
| Hanna Wolf (München) | x | |||
| Waltraud Wolff (Wolmirstedt) | x | |||
| Heidemarie Wright | x | |||
| Uta Zapf | x | |||
| Dr. Christoph Zöpel | x | |||
| Name | Drucksache
14/8101 |
Drucksache
14/8102 |
Nein | Enthaltung |
| CDU/CSU | ||||
| Ulrich Adam | x | |||
| Ilse Aigner | x | |||
| Peter Altmaier | x | |||
| Dietrich Austermann | x | |||
| Norbert Barthle | x | |||
| Dr. Wolf Bauer | x | |||
| Günter Baumann | x | |||
| Brigitte Baumeister | x | |||
| Meinrad Belle | x | |||
| Dr. Sabine Bergmann-Pohl | x | |||
| Otto Bernhardt | x | |||
| Dr. Joseph-Theodor Blank | x | |||
| Renate Blank | x | |||
| Dr. Heribert Blens | x | |||
| Peter Bleser | x | |||
| Antje Blumenthal | x | |||
| Friedrich Bohl | x | |||
| Dr. Maria Böhmer | x | |||
| Sylvia Bonitz | x | |||
| Jochen Borchert | x | |||
| Wolfgang Börnsen (Bönstrup) | x | |||
| Wolfgang Bosbach | x | |||
| Dr. Wolfgang Bötsch | x | |||
| Klaus Brähmig | x | |||
| Dr. Ralf Brauksiepe | x | |||
| Paul Breuer | x | |||
| Monika Brudlewsky | x | |||
| Georg Brunnhuber | x | |||
| Hartmut Büttner (Schönebeck) | x | |||
| Dankward Buwitt | x | |||
| Cajus Caesar | x | |||
| Manfred Carstens (Emstek) | x | |||
| Peter H. Carstensen (Nordstrand) | x | |||
| Leo Dautzenberg | x | |||
| Wolfgang Dehnel | x | |||
| Hubert Deittert | x | |||
| Albert Deß | x | |||
| Renate Diemers | x | |||
| Thomas Dörflinger | x | |||
| Dr. Hansjürgen Doss | x | |||
| Marie-Luise Dött | x | |||
| Maria Eichhorn | x | |||
| Anke Eymer (Lübeck) | x | |||
| Ilse Falk | x | |||
| Dr. Hans Georg Faust | x | |||
| Albrecht Feibel | x | |||
| Ulf Fink | x | |||
| Ingrid Fischbach | x | |||
| Dirk Fischer (Hamburg) | x | |||
| Axel E. Fischer (Karlsruhe-Land) | x | |||
| Klaus Francke | x | |||
| Herbert Frankenhauser | x | |||
| Dr. Hans-Peter Friedrich (Hof) | x | |||
| Erich G. Fritz | x | |||
| Jochen-Konrad Fromme | x | |||
| Hans-Joachim Fuchtel | x | |||
| Dr. Jürgen Gehb | x | |||
| Norbert Geis | x | |||
| Georg Girisch | x | |||
| Michael Glos | x | |||
| Dr. Reinhard Göhner | x | |||
| Peter Götz | x | |||
| Dr. Wolfgang Götzer | x | |||
| Kurt-Dieter Grill | x | |||
| Hermann Gröhe | x | |||
| Manfred Grund | x | |||
| Gottfried Haschke (Großhennersdorf ) | x | |||
| Gerda Hasselfeldt | x | |||
| Norbert Hauser (Bonn) | x | |||
| Hansgeorg Hauser (Rednitzhembach) | x | |||
| Klaus-Jürgen Hedrich | x | |||
| Helmut Heiderich | x | |||
| Ursula Heinen | x | |||
| Manfred Heise | x | |||
| Siegfried Helias | x | |||
| Hans Jochen Henke | x | |||
| Ernst Hinsken | x | |||
| Peter Hintze | x | |||
| Klaus Hofbauer | x | |||
| Klaus Holetschek | x | |||
| Josef Hollerith | x | |||
| Dr. Karl-Heinz Hornhues | x | |||
| Siegfried Hornung | x | |||
| Joachim Hörster | x | |||
| Hubert Hüppe | x | |||
| Georg Janovsky | x | |||
| Dr.-Ing. Rainer Jork | x | |||
| Dr. Harald Kahl | x | |||
| Bartholomäus Kalb | x | |||
| Steffen Kampeter | x | |||
| Dr.-Ing. Dietmar Kansy | x | |||
| Irmgard Karwatzki | x | |||
| Volker Kauder | x | |||
| Eckart von Klaeden | x | |||
| Ulrich Klinkert | x | |||
| Dr. Helmut Kohl | x | |||
| Norbert Königshofen | x | |||
| Eva-Maria Kors | x | |||
| Hartmut Koschyk | x | |||
| Rudolf Kraus | x | |||
| Dr. Martina Krogmann | x | |||
| Dr. Hermann Kues | x | |||
| Werner Kuhn | x | |||
| Karl Lamers | x | |||
| Dr. Karl A. Lamers (Heidelberg) | x | |||
| Dr. Norbert Lammert | x | |||
| Helmut Lamp | x | |||
| Dr. Paul Laufs | x | |||
| Karl-Josef Laumann | x | |||
| Vera Lengsfeld | x | |||
| Werner Lensing | x | |||
| Peter Letzgus | x | |||
| Ursula Lietz | x | |||
| Walter Link (Diepholz) | x | |||
| Eduard Lintner | x | |||
| Dr. Klaus W. Lippold (Offenbach) | x | |||
| Dr. Manfred Lischewski | x | |||
| Wolfgang Lohmann (Lüdenscheid) | x | |||
| Julius Louven | x | |||
| Dr. Michael Luther | x | |||
| Erich Maaß (Wilhelmshaven) | x | |||
| Erwin Marschewski (Recklinghausen) | x | |||
| Dr. Martin Mayer (Siegertsbrunn) | x | |||
| Wolfgang Meckelburg | x | |||
| Dr. Michael Meister | x | |||
| Dr. Angela Merkel | x | |||
| Friedrich Merz | x | |||
| Hans Michelbach | x | |||
| Meinolf Michels | x | |||
| Dr. Gerd Müller | x | |||
| Bernward Müller (Jena) | x | |||
| Elmar Müller (Kirchheim) | x | |||
| Bernd Neumann (Bremen) | x | |||
| Claudia Nolte | x | |||
| Günter Nooke | x | |||
| Franz Obermeier | x | |||
| Friedhelm Ost | x | |||
| Eduard Oswald | x | |||
| Norbert Otto (Erfurt) | x | |||
| Dr. Peter Paziorek | x | |||
| Anton Pfeifer | x | |||
| Dr. Friedbert Pflüger | x | |||
| Beatrix Philipp | x | |||
| Ronald Pofalla | x | |||
| Ruprecht Polenz | x | |||
| Marlies Pretzlaff | x | |||
| Dr. Bernd Protzner | x | |||
| Thomas Rachel | x | |||
| Hans Raidel | x | |||
| Dr. Peter Ramsauer | x | |||
| Peter Rauen | x | |||
| Christa Reichard (Dresden) | x | |||
| Katherina Reiche | x | |||
| Erika Reinhardt | x | |||
| Hans-Peter Repnik | x | |||
| Klaus Riegert | x | |||
| Dr. Heinz Riesenhuber | x | |||
| Franz Romer | x | |||
| Hannelore Rönsch (Wiesbaden) | x | |||
| Heinrich-Wilhelm Ronsöhr | x | |||
| Dr. Klaus Rose | x | |||
| Kurt J. Rossmanith | x | |||
| Adolf Roth (Gießen) | x | |||
| Dr. Norbert Röttgen | x | |||
| Dr. Christian Ruck | x | |||
| Volker Rühe | x | |||
| Anita Schäfer | x | |||
| Dr. Wolfgang Schäuble | x | |||
| Hartmut Schauerte | x | |||
| Heinz Schemken | x | |||
| Karl-Heinz Scherhag | x | |||
| Dr. Gerhard Scheu | x | |||
| Norbert Schindler | x | |||
| Dietmar Schlee | x | |||
| Bernd Schmidbauer | x | |||
| Christian Schmidt (Fürth) | x | |||
| Dr.-Ing. Joachim Schmidt (Halsbrücke) | x | |||
| Andreas Schmidt (Mülheim) | x | |||
| Michael von Schmude | x | |||
| Dr. Andreas Schockenhoff | x | |||
| Dr. Rupert Scholz | x | |||
| Reinhard Freiherr von Schorlemer | x | |||
| Dr. Erika Schuchardt | x | |||
| Wolfgang Schulhoff | x | |||
| Gerhard Schulz | x | |||
| Clemens Schwalbe | x | |||
| Dr. Christian Schwarz-Schilling | x | |||
| Wilhelm Josef Sebastian | x | |||
| Heinz Seiffert | x | |||
| Dr. h. c. Rudolf Seiters | x | |||
| Bernd Siebert | x | |||
| Werner Siemann | x | |||
| Johannes Singhammer | x | |||
| Bärbel Sothmann | x | |||
| Margarete Späte | x | |||
| Carl-Dieter Spranger | x | |||
| Wolfgang Steiger | x | |||
| Erika Steinbach | x | |||
| Dr. Wolfgang Freiherr von Stetten | x | |||
| Andreas Storm | x | |||
| Dorothea Störr-Ritter | x | |||
| Max Straubinger | x | |||
| Thomas Strobl (Heilbronn) | x | |||
| Michael Stübgen | x | |||
| Dr. Rita Süssmuth | x | |||
| Dr. Susanne Tiemann | x | |||
| Edeltraut Töpfer | x | |||
| Dr. Hans-Peter Uhl | x | |||
| Arnold Vaatz | x | |||
| Angelika Volquartz | x | |||
| Andrea Voßhoff | x | |||
| Dr. Theodor Waigel | x | |||
| Peter Weiß (Emmendingen) | x | |||
| Annette Widmann-Mauz | x | |||
| Heinz Wiese (Ehingen) | x | |||
| Hans-Otto Wilhelm (Mainz) | x | |||
| Klaus-Peter Willsch | x | |||
| Bernd Wilz | x | |||
| Willy Wimmer (Neuss) | x | |||
| Matthias Wissmann | x | |||
| Werner Wittlich | x | |||
| Dagmar Wöhrl | x | |||
| Aribert Wolf | x | |||
| Elke Wülfing | x | |||
| Peter Kurt Würzbach | x | |||
| Wolfgang Zeitlmann | x | |||
| Benno Zierer | x | |||
| Wolfgang Zöller | x | |||
| Name | Drucksache
14/8101 |
Drucksache
14/8102 |
Nein | Enthaltung |
| BÜNDNIS 90/DIE GRÜNEN | ||||
| Gila Altmann (Aurich) | x | |||
| Volker Beck (Köln) | x | |||
| Angelika Beer | x | |||
| Matthias Berninger | x | |||
| Grietje Bettin | x | |||
| Annelie Buntenbach | x | |||
| Ekin Deligöz | x | |||
| Dr. Thea Dückert | x | |||
| Franziska Eichstädt-Bohlig | x | |||
| Dr. Uschi Eid | x | |||
| Hans-Josef Fell | x | |||
| Andrea Fischer (Berlin) | x | |||
| Joseph Fischer (Frankfurt) | x | |||
| Katrin Göring-Eckardt | x | |||
| Rita Grießhaber | x | |||
| Gerald Häfner | x | |||
| Winfried Hermann | x | |||
| Antje Hermenau | x | |||
| Ulrike Höfken | x | |||
| Michaele Hustedt | x | |||
| Monika Knoche | x | |||
| Dr. Angelika Köster-Loßack | x | |||
| Steffi Lemke | x | |||
| Dr. Helmut Lippelt | x | |||
| Dr. Reinhard Loske | x | |||
| Oswald Metzger | x | |||
| Kerstin Müller (Köln) | x | |||
| Winfried Nachtwei | x | |||
| Christa Nickels | x | |||
| Cem Özdemir | x | |||
| Simone Probst | x | |||
| Christine Scheel | x | |||
| Irmingard Schewe-Gerigk | x | |||
| Rezzo Schlauch | x | |||
| Albert Schmidt (Hitzhofen) | x | |||
| Werner Schulz (Leipzig) | x | |||
| Christian Simmert | x | |||
| Christian Sterzing | x | |||
| Hans-Christian Ströbele | x | |||
| Jürgen Trittin | x | |||
| Dr. Antje Vollmer | x | |||
| Dr. Ludger Volmer | x | |||
| Sylvia Voß | x | |||
| Helmut Wilhelm (Amberg) | x | |||
| Margareta Wolf (Frankfurt) | x | |||
| Name | Drucksache
14/8101 |
Drucksache
14/8102 |
Nein | Enthaltung |
| FDP | ||||
| Ina Albowitz | x | |||
| Hildebrecht Braun (Augsburg) | x | |||
| Rainer Brüderle | x | |||
| Ernst Burgbacher | x | |||
| Jörg van Essen | x | |||
| Ulrike Flach | x | |||
| Gisela Frick | x | |||
| Paul K. Friedhoff | x | |||
| Rainer Funke | x | |||
| Dr. Wolfgang Gerhardt | x | |||
| Hans-Michael Goldmann | x | |||
| Joachim Günther (Plauen) | x | |||
| Dr. Karlheinz Guttmacher | x | |||
| Klaus Haupt | x | |||
| Dr. Helmut Haussmann | x | |||
| Ulrich Heinrich | x | |||
| Walter Hirche | x | |||
| Birgit Homburger | x | |||
| Dr. Werner Hoyer | x | |||
| Ulrich Irmer | x | |||
| Dr. Klaus Kinkel | x | |||
| Dr. Heinrich L. Kolb | x | |||
| Gudrun Kopp | x | |||
| Jürgen Koppelin | x | |||
| Ina Lenke | x | |||
| Sabine Leutheusser-Schnarrenberger | x | |||
| Dirk Niebel | x | |||
| Günther Friedrich Nolting | x | |||
| Hans-Joachim Otto (Frankfurt) | x | |||
| Detlef Parr | x | |||
| Cornelia Pieper | x | |||
| Dr. Günter Rexrodt | x | |||
| Dr. Edzard Schmidt-Jortzig | x | |||
| Gerhard Schüßler | x | |||
| Dr. Irmgard Schwaetzer | x | |||
| Marita Sehn | x | |||
| Dr. Hermann Otto Solms | x | |||
| Dr. Max Stadler | x | |||
| Carl-Ludwig Thiele | x | |||
| Dr. Dieter Thomae | x | |||
| Jürgen Türk | x | |||
| Dr. Guido Westerwelle | x | |||
| Name | Drucksache
14/8101 |
Drucksache
14/8102 |
Nein | Enthaltung |
| PDS | ||||
| Dr. Dietmar Bartsch | x | |||
| Petra Bläss | x | |||
| Maritta Böttcher | x | |||
| Eva Bulling-Schröter | x | |||
| Roland Claus | x | |||
| Dr. Heinrich Fink | x | |||
| Dr. Ruth Fuchs | x | |||
| Wolfgang Gehrcke | x | |||
| Dr. Klaus Grehn | x | |||
| Dr. Gregor Gysi | x | |||
| Uwe Hiksch | x | |||
| Dr. Barbara Höll | x | |||
| Carsten Hübner | x | |||
| Ulla Jelpke | x | |||
| Sabine Jünger | x | |||
| Gerhard Jüttemann | x | |||
| Dr. Evelyn Kenzler | x | |||
| Rolf Kutzmutz | x | |||
| Heidi Lippmann | x | |||
| Dr. Christa Luft | x | |||
| Heidemarie Lüth | x | |||
| Pia Maier | x | |||
| Manfred Müller (Berlin) | x | |||
| Kersten Naumann | x | |||
| Rosel Neuhäuser | x | |||
| Christine Ostrowski | x | |||
| Petra Pau | x | |||
| Dr. Uwe-Jens Rössel | x | |||
| Christina Schenk | x | |||
| Gustav-Adolf Schur | x | |||
| Dr. Ilja Seifert | x | |||
| Dr. Winfried Wolf | x | |||
| Name | Drucksache
14/8101 |
Drucksache
14/8102 |
Nein | Enthaltung |
| Fraktionslose Abgeordnete | ||||
| Christa Lörcher | x |
